Description: A debate between Luck (situation) or Providence (God pulling strings) implies that humans are pawns. Not so; God wishes and expects our participation.
Luck or Providence? (Romans 8:28)
Sermon Transcript by Rev. Ernest O’Neill
Karl Marx described religion as “the opium of the masses” you remember. Do you know what he meant
by that? Really, he meant that a verse like “all things work together for good to them that love
God”, which is the popular translation of Romans 8:28 – a verse like that was being used by the
governing classes to keep the proletariat, or the people, or the workers, or the masses from being
discontented with their lot. And so he said, you see it is the opium of the masses, it’s the drug
that keeps people lulled into a contentment with their present lot. And so he regarded religion as
one of the instruments that the governing classes used to keep the workers and the peasants under
their control. And really it is a common misinterpretation loved ones of Romans 8:28.
That is, the idea that your present state is God’s absolute ideal best for you and so don’t question
it, just stay exactly where you are and if God wants to change it he’ll change it for you, but you
just accept it as it is and don’t do anything about it. It sounds close to Christian contentment
except that it lays emphasis on the fact that if anything is to happen to change it God will do it,
don’t you do anything about it. And it lays emphasis on the fact that this is God’s absolute ideal
best for you. Not his permissive will for you under the circumstances, but his absolute ideal best
— so you just stay where you are — and rest at that. What it results in is of course disastrous.
It results in absolute social irresponsibility, personal passivity, and just a readiness to let
things remain as they are for the rest of your life and really it is the kind of fatalism that runs
through eastern religions.
Things are as they are today because the gods have ordained it this way. It is this kind of
passivity that has paralyzed a sleeping giant like India. The economy hangs in chaos because people
are continually thinking, “Well all things work together for good. Things are as good as they can
be. We can’t do anything about it and the next life will bring an improvement. So, let’s not rock
the boat, let’s just keep it as it is.” And really loved ones, I think that attitude runs through a
lot of people who say they believe in the Father of Jesus. They have this idea that you can’t
change it and it’s not your responsibility to change it. Your destiny is fixed by God’s will
irrespective of whether your will cooperates or fails to cooperate with him or not, just take it as
true. All things work together for good to them that love God. It will all come out right in the
end. You just bear with it, put up. And so loved ones, I think many of us really do just that.
We have the idea that the will of God has determined the way our lives will go and all we can do is
accept them and know that somehow things will come out right in the end. Now loved ones because of
that misinterpretation of the verse I think it is good to read the Revised Standard Version and
maybe you would do that. It’s Romans 8:28
“We know that in everything God works for good with those who love him, who are called according to
his purpose.” “We know that in everything God works for good with those who love him, who are
called according to his purpose.” Now do you see loved ones, it doesn’t say all THINGS work for
good — because that’s of course where that fatalistic streak comes into Christianity and rules the
eastern religions. The idea that these mighty forces and events and circumstances, they work
themselves out for good. They impress themselves upon my life, they are the impersonal,
domineering, overwhelming force that is exerted by a divine puppeteer up there and I can do nothing
about it. That’s the impression that comes over when you make all THINGS work together for good as
the subject of the sentence. You get the impression, all things, well yeah but who works the “all
things” or what are the “all things”? Well, they are just events. Whereas, you can see here the
Bible says, “God works for good and works for good with those who love him.”
In other words, it is not God operating independent of you and me, it’s God working together with
us. He does some things and we do some things. God, you remember, we said two weeks ago, will not
act against his own will but he cannot act apart from our wills. God cannot just come down and
touch a dear one who is under cancer unless some of us realize he wants to do that and asks him to
do it. That’s why you remember Jesus said, “Be it unto you according to your faith.” Not according
to the movements of blind, impersonal, faithful circumstances, but be it unto you according to your
faith. As you believe so God will be able to act in your life.
It ties up with other verses. First Corinthians 3:9 talks about us being coworkers together with
God. So the whole teaching of Scripture is that God works with us and he does some things and we do
some things. This is the real answer to Marx and to his accusation. It is the real answer to all
critics of Christianity that down through history God has worked with people. And so the first
schools were started in the western world by Christians who believed that God would use them to
renew people’s minds. The first hospitals in the western worlds were started by Christians who
believed that God would use them to heal people’s bodies. The first trade unions in England were
started by Christians who believed that God would use them to bring justice into the economic world.
The first scientists were Christians who believed that God would use it to restore order to his
world. Every piece of progress that has occurred in the western world has come from people who
believed that if they took a step, the Father would take a step.
And it’s completely different from this other attitude that says, “Oh no, it will all work itself
Now, loved ones it is also different from another attitude. Do you see that it is not man passive
and God active. That’s the fatalism of eastern religions and of much of Christendom: man passive
and God active. But, neither is it man active and God passive, man doing everything and God doing
nothing. Which I would remind you is the real spirit that lies behind popular idioms like “you’re
the answer to your own prayers”. No, you can’t be the answer to your own prayers. There are some
things that you can’t do with all your prayers; you’re not the answer to your own prayers. Or “God
helps those who help themselves. Get out, God helps those who help themselves.” No, it’s God works
together with us. God wills and reveals his will to us — what he wants to do in a situation. We
perceive his will and either believe accordingly or obey accordingly and then God releases his power
into the situation.
Now do you see that loved ones? I should just mention it again. God has a will for every
situation in our lives today. He knows exactly what he wants to do in your present situation. Now
he wants to reveal that to you so that you can begin to work together with him on it. Otherwise he
may want this chair moved over here and you’re busy tugging it over here and you’re going this way
and he’s going that way. So God wants to reveal his will to you and you perceive his will and then
he lets you know whether you are to obey him in a certain area or believe him for a certain thing.
And, in the light of your response to God he releases his power in to the situation. And that’s what
this verse means, “God works for good with those who love him.”
Now loved ones an example of it would be I King 18:22. There was one prophet left, you remember in
Israel — and about 500 prophets of the Asherah and 50 prophets of Baal, 450 prophets of Baal. I
Kings 18:22. “Then Elijah said to the people, ‘I, even I only, am left a prophet of the LORD; but
Baal’s prophets are four hundred and fifty men. Let two bulls be given to us; and let them choose
one bull for themselves, and cut it in pieces and lay it on the wood, but put no fire to it; and I
will prepare the other bull and lay it on the wood, and put no fire to it. And you call on the name
of your god and I will call on the name of the LORD; and the God who answers by fire, he is God.’
And all the people answered, ‘It is well spoken.’”
Elijah did not say, “There are 450 prophets of Baal and there are 500 prophets of Asherah. Well,
just let’s sit here. All things work together for good for them that love him.” He knew that the
Father would work with him if he could see what the Father wanted to do. And so he sought God’s
will and saw what God wanted to do and he did his part.
Then would you look to verse 37. “’Answer me, O LORD, answer me,’” — and he believed God —
“’That this people may know that thou, O LORD, art God, and that thou hast turned their hearts
back.’ Then the fire of the LORD fell, and consumed the burnt offering, and the wood, and the
stones, and the dust, and licked up the water that was in the trench. And when all the people saw
it, they fell on their faces; and they said, ‘The LORD, he is God; the LORD, he is God.’” So
that’s God’s way of working.
Now would you go back with me to Romans 8:28, loved ones. Do you see the first two words in the
verse, the first two words? “We know.” Now, how do we know? Now the strange thing is that you
don’t know through other people telling you how God worked out some bad situations that they were
in. It is very interesting, but that’s not how you come to an assurance that God will do the same
in your life. It’s strange, you think it will. I used to think, “If somebody would tell me how
they were helped out of a hideous situation, I knew it would help me.” And, it appears to help us,
but actually we can always deceive ourselves into believing that our situation is worse than theirs
was. And so other people’s experiences don’t really reassure us. They may confirm the method by
which we really know. How do we really know? We know because Jesus is God’s son and he was always
doing that kind of thing himself.
He came along to some lepers and he healed them. He came along to a woman caught in adultery and
being accused by all other religious leaders and he forgave her. He came along to somebody else who
had lost something and he helped them. And Jesus says, “He that hath seen me has seen the father.”
And we know that our Creator is like Jesus. Every time Jesus came to a situation which was bad he
started to work to improve it. He never left it, he always began to improve it and change it. And
so we know Jesus always did that kind of thing. Moreover, he himself says that his Father does this
kind of thing.
Would you look at that where it says that. It’s Luke 12:27. Jesus says, “Consider the lilies, how
they grow; they neither toil nor spin; yet I tell you, even Solomon in all his glory was not arrayed
like one of these. But if God so clothes the grass which is alive in the field today and tomorrow
is thrown into the oven, how much more will he clothe you, O men of little faith! And do not seek
what you are to eat and what you are to drink, nor be of anxious mind. For all the nations of the
world seek these things; and your Father knows that you need them. Instead, seek his kingdom, and
these things shall be yours as well.”
And Jesus says, “The Father knows what you need in every situation.” And he is always working to
change and transform the situation. He’s the one that made it so that when you unzip the old skin
it automatically zips up itself. He made it that way. He didn’t make it so that it zips opens and
stays open and you bleed to death every time you get a cut. He’s the one that made it so that there
are healing powers that every time a thing goes wrong, a power works to make it right. The Father
is the one who thought of these things, loved ones. He’s the one who makes things heal. He’s the
one who has built into our world constant repair mechanisms that operate to bring health and bring
success and victory to us. So Jesus is saying, “Look, my Father is that kind of person. Every time
he comes into a situation that is bad, he’s always working to improve it.” God is always working in
everything. With those of us who love him, he’s always working with us for good. And so the
reason we know that God does this kind of thing is because we know his nature. It’s not by all the
experiences that people tell us about, it’s because we know this is the kind of God our God is. He
doesn’t come by and see a person who has been robbed and leave them lying in a ditch, he begins to
work with them to rectify the situation.
So I know that he is doing it in my situation. I know Father that you are trying to get through to
me, you’re trying to show me what you want to do to change my situation. Lord thank you. And of
course, we can see that that is the kind of way he operated down through the years in the Bible.
Maybe you’d look at old Joseph, who I think could probably beat any of us in catastrophes and
tragedies. Genesis 37. And it is just an up and down alternating experience of tragedy and triumph
right through. Genesis 37:3. “Now Israel loved Joseph more than any other of his children
because he was the son of his old age; and he made him a long robe with sleeves. But when his
brothers saw that their father loved him more than all his brothers, they hated him, and could not
speak peaceably to him.” And then verse 23, “So when Joseph came to his brothers, they stripped him
of his robe, the long robe with sleeves that he wore; and they took him and cast him into a pit. The
pit was empty, there was no water in it.” And then verse 28, “Then Midianite traders passed by; and
they drew Joseph up and lifted him out of the pit, and sold him to the Ishmaelites for twenty
shekels of silver; and they took Joseph to Egypt.” But God was working all the time.
And Genesis 39:1-5: “Now Joseph was taken down to Egypt, and Poti-phar, an officer of Pharaoh, the
captain of the guard, an Egyptian, bought him from the Ishmaelites who had brought him down there.
The LORD was with Joseph, and he became a successful man; and he was in the house of his master the
Egyptian, and his master saw that the LORD was with him, and that the LORD caused all that he did
to prosper in his hands. So Joseph found favor in his sight and attended him, and he made him
overseer of his house and put him in charge of all that he had. From the time that he made him
overseer in his house and over all that he had the LORD blessed the Egyptian’s house for Joseph’s
sake; the blessing of the LORD was upon all that he had, in house and field.” And then in Genesis
39:19, you remember Potiphar’s wife compromised Joseph by lying in Verse 19. “When his master heard
the words which his wife spoke to him, ‘This is the way your servant treated me,’ his anger was
kindled. And Joseph’s master took him and put him into the prison, the place where the king’s
prisoners were confined, and he was there in prison.” But again God is working together with him
for good. “But the LORD was with Joseph and showed him steadfast love, and gave him favor in the
sight of the keeper of the prison. And the keeper of the prison committed to Joseph’s care all the
prisoners who were in the prison; and whatever was done there, he was the doer of it.” And, God
continues to work with him.
Genesis 41:37. You remember Pharaoh has a dream and Joseph is called for out of the prison. “His
proposal seemed good to Pharaoh and to all his servants. And Pharaoh said to his servants, ‘Can we
find such a man as this, in whom is the Spirit of God?’ So Pharaoh said to Joseph, ‘Since God has
shown you all this, there is none so discreet and wise as you are; you shall be over my house, and
all my people shall order themselves as you command; only as regards the throne will I be greater
than you.’ And Pharaoh said to Joseph, ‘Behold, I have set you over all the land of Egypt’.”
And we know that if God worked that way with Joseph he is the same yesterday, today, and forever,
and he is operating the same way with us today and that God does continues to work with us. And
loved ones we know that God does this because of the kind of person he is — because he’s done this
in the past and because every time Satan operates in our lives God is immediately working out how to
transform it. And that is the meaning of that verse that I think it would be good if you just look
at — and then I will promise not to trail you through too many more.
It’s 1Corinthians 10:13. Because it makes it just very plain to us that God is never caught out but
that he’s always really one step ahead. “No temptation has overtaken you that is not common to man.
God is faithful, and he will not let you be tempted beyond your strength, but with the temptation
will also provide the way of escape, that you may be able to endure it.” In other words, we know
from God‘s own word that he’ll never allow us to be beaten and destroyed by anything and that he’ll
only allow it to take place up to the point where we can bear it and immediately if that happens he
will be working out a way of escape. So immediately Satan comes into our lives with some
destruction or catastrophe, God we know is immediately beginning to show us a way out of it. That’s
what he means, he’s beginning to provide a way of escape.
That’s why it says in the Bible that God will not quench the flickering torch. He will not allow
events to so come upon you that you are destroyed by them, that’s you remember the power that he has
over Satan. Loved ones it is not a dualism; it is not God fighting Satan and we’re not sure who
will win. It is God using even Satan’s workings to strengthen us and test us and to draw us closer
to himself. That’s the meaning of that interview you remember at the beginning of the book of Job.
You remember, Satan comes to God and God asks him, “Where have you been?” He says, “I have been
roaming throughout the world.” And God says, “What have you to say to me?” And
Satan says, “Well look at that man Job.” And God says, “Yeah look at him, he is a man that never
rebels against me.” And Satan says, “Yeah, that is because you have set a hedge round about him; he
has all that he needs. He is prosperous and rich, he has a family, he is respected by his
neighbors, that’s why he respects you.” And then God said, “Behold he is in your hands. Do
whatever you want only don’t take his life.”
And if you look at the first chapter of Job loved ones this afternoon, you’ll see that God has
control of Satan, that the things that come about in your life are not happening without God’s
permission, God does not send them. But when Satan operates, God allows through his dear loving
fingers only what you’re able to bear and so everything that happens to you has been filtered
through the loving hands of your own Father and the only reason he is letting them come through is
because he himself is going to use that situation to draw you nearer to himself and that is what it
means when we say, “God works together for good with those who love him.” God is always doing that
and so dear ones, that’s why we can really do what the Bible says. You know, treat it as pure joy
when you enter into various trials because for us they are not the terrible, wild, impersonal
results of a hideous power of evil in this world. They are the events that our loving Father is
allowing to come into our lives so that he may use them for good with us.
Now, just before taking a couple of examples, could I point out two truths about the way an ordinary
father would deal with an ordinary son. An ordinary father would get his little boy up every
morning early because he knows that the burden of self indulgence will be greater for the poor
fellow to bear if he is allowed to continue in it in his life than the burden of self-discipline. In
fact, the father knows that eventually the boy’s control over his own body and being able to make
his body do what he wants it to do will bring a certain exhilaration and satisfaction to him. So
just one fact, the father sees deeper than the boy, do you see that? The father can see that though
it appears bad to the boy at the time, he can see that further along the way it’s going to turn into
the boy’s good. So just in ordinary relationships here, often the father can see deeper than the
son. He can see behind the event and can see the good that he’s going to bring from it.
Secondly, the father has the boy bear all that he can possibly bear at that time, because the father
knows it will produce all the greater strengths and discipline in the boy. And yet, when he sees the
little guy beginning to crack under it, he’ll pull back. And so it is important for us to see that
at the very beginning of our Christian lives, the Father very often works everything very obviously
and plainly for our good, because we’re such poor little mites we need encouragement. And then as
we grow bigger he begins to ask us to take longer journeys simply believing that the good is his
good and he is judging it rightly. I know to us it appears bad yet he is making it good to us and
working it good for us. So the second fact is that God himself will often deal with us according to
our maturity or our immaturity.
Now, this can be seen in all the instances that we’ve had in our body. Brian Gibdel dived into the
lake you remember in the summertime, struck the bottom of the lake and broke his neck. And you
remember we started to pray for him because he was absolutely paralyzed. And, I don’t know if his
mum is here, but she was if you remember – well, there he is, he’s sitting in the second row. That
spoils my story. So he was lying in bed you know, and I remember your mum coming and saying, or it
was Judy I think came and said, “Yeah, Brian he just lies there with tears running down his cheeks.”
He couldn’t talk or do anything, absolutely paralyzed.
And you remember, ,his mum would come and she’d share and we’d pray and you remember how it worked,
I mean you could tell it wasn’t luck because she’d come and say, “he can’t talk” and so we’d pray
and he could talk. Then she’d come and say, if he could only lift his hand up like that, you know –
and so you pray so he could move his hand and now there he is and he was hiking with his dad and all
that kind of thing. Don’t know if he is skiing yet, but okay. That’s God working for good to them
that love him. That’s plain and obvious, that’s very plain and very obvious to us all.
Now I don’t know, is Chris Vork here? Maybe she isn’t. No? I married Chris a year – two years
ago. She’s 22, she married Bob Vork. Bob is just a man’s man in every ways, you know. A graduate
of Bethel, artist and a comedian, and just a dear fellow. All those of you who know Bob’s name know
that. And we married – I think they married in Bethel Chapel. And, there they are you know, a
handsome couple and life just opening up just beautiful before them. And, a year and a half ago, no
eight months ago, Bob was teaching in Braham, up north and he and Chris were in the Volkswagen going
along a country road late at night and saw these lights coming towards them on the wrong side of the
road. I don’t know that the driver was drunk but he certainly wasn‘t in control of the thing. Bob
of course, pulled the old car right up into a ditch to try at least to save Chris. And, of course,
the thing just plowed into them. Chris looked down at him and she knew he was dead at that moment.
And, immediately, she seemed to have a complete confidence in that situation that God was going to
work for good.
She had been very dependent on Bob and I suppose like many girls at the beginning, you know, our
husband is everything to us, and it was with her. She was very dependent and very quiet – that’s
why I wonder if she is here and just keeping quiet. But, she is very quiet and very shy and very
reluctant to take initiative on her own, but at that moment had a great assurance that God was
working for good in this situation with her. And so she went into the other truck and prayed with
the other guys who were trembling and shaking. I did the funeral and I know that she was just
victorious throughout the whole thing.
Now some of you know the rest of the story because God has continued to work for good in her. From
being shy and dependant on her husband, she came in you remember to the restaurant about five or six
months ago and it was just magnificent. She was head waitress in the restaurant for the past four
or five months and just has been a blessing in the place and moved the furniture that she and Bob
had gathered together and moved it down here into an apartment and three weeks ago she came to me
— this shy dependent girl whom all of us should began to treat as a tragic young widow, right?
Isn’t that it? A tragic young widow that we weep with and we sorrow with. This dear daughter of God
came to me three weeks ago and said, “Pastor, I really think God wants me to go to London.” So
tomorrow morning she will fly to London to begin to run the dining room in a restaurant.
And that’s God working together for good with her. You say to me, “What about Bob?” Bob knew
Jesus. Obviously the Father could have stopped the fellow running into him, but God knows that he
has another world to populate and the Father knows what need he has for Bob in that world and what
need he has for Chris in this world. And so God works for good in everything to those who love him,
to those who really want to please him. But loved ones, do you see it brings about a totally
different attitude to catastrophes. That’s why you remember one sister back there one Sunday said,
“My mother died of cancer.” So here is Brian being healed but here is a mum dying of cancer. So
here is Bob being killed in a car accident, but here is Chris coming out of it with joy and with
victory. And so loved ones, the good is not always immediately obvious to us, but God does work for
good with those of us who love him. who are called according to his purpose.
And so these situations that you’re in — would you stop looking down, would you stop treating them
as if Satan is in control — and would you begin to see that you have a loving Father who knows
what’s happening to you and has already a plan of deliverance for you. He’s just waiting for you to
find out from him what he wants you to do. And instead of sitting around and moping and cursing God
and cursing your luck, would you look up to your dear Father and see that this verse is true, that
God works together for good with those of us who love him and are called according to his purpose —
and that he does immediately the tragedy occurs.
Well, I pray that God will help you to see it because it just transforms life.
Would you just pray, loved ones.
Dear Father, we thank you for your clear word and by it we know that in everything God works for
good with those who love him, who are called according to his purpose. And, we thank you Lord, that
that is true and that that will be true this coming week for us in the little tragedies: in the
dead battery, in the failure of the lights, right up to the major tragedies, the death of our loved
ones, the loss of our jobs. Father we thank you, that you are saying to us, “Look up, look up, my
hand is upon that situation and I have already planned a new way for you to operate and to go. Look
up to me and see what I want you to do now and I am going to work this for good with you.”
Lord thank you, thank you, thank you that you are doing it at this very moment in each one of our
lives and all we have to do is look up and begin to live, begin to rejoice instead of sorrow. Thank
you, Lord. Thank you that you cannot be beat and that Satan can never catch you unawares, thank you
Lord. Now the grace of our Lord Jesus and the love of God and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be
with each one of us now and evermore. Amen
Comments : Luck or Providence?
Leave a Comment
Start a Discussion
Indepth Discussions : Luck or Providence?
It Appears there are no Group Discussions for this talk - Click " Start a Discussion " Green Toggle above to create the first one.